This new mini episode of Nailed It! is quite chilling, especially when you see what the competitors conjured up in their cauldrons.

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina stars and Nailed It! fans Kiernan Shipka, Miranda Otto, and Lucy Davis helped the comical cooking fail show mark its season 3 premiere on Netflix with their own special challenge.

Each witchy actress was tasked with creating a cake based on one of three hunks from their own Netflix series: Harvey (Ross Lynch), Nick (Gavin Leatherwood), or Satan himself (Luke Cook).

Otto, in true Aunt Zelda style, brought a hammer to help her. (The same hammer Zelda once used to put her sister in the Lazarus Pit?!) And Davis, reminding us all not to underestimate Aunt Hilda, whipped out her own secret baking mix. All three contestants had to create a star-shaped cake base and then recreate edible man treats.

NAILED IT Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Crossover CR: Adam Rose/Netflix
Credit: Adam Rose/Netflix

Their castmate Chance Perdomo (Ambrose) couldn’t be there, but when Davis hit her Take a Chance buzzer for an assist, a recorded message from Perdomo popped up to give her a three-minute advantage over the others.

In the end, it was Kiernan with her salute to Nicholas Scratch who won the day… even though all the butter she used might send the judges’ souls to Lucifer Morningstar a bit too soon. Watch the video above for more.

Related content:

Episode Recaps

Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
  • TV Show
  • 3