By Nick Romano
April 11, 2019 at 09:42 AM EDT

New Yorkers see some pretty weird stuff on a daily basis, but in the tourist trap that is Rockefeller Plaza, Jimmy Fallon and Drew Barrymore loosely disguised as NBC pages lip syncing and dancing were a sight.

Fallon dressed up as Alex and Barrymore dressed up as Brooke, their page personas, for Wednesday’s The Tonight Show and moved to “The Loco-Motion” by Little Eva. It’s hard to go “undercover,” though, when you’re lip syncing and dancing straight to camera, so they naturally garnered a crowd following. The two seemed to have a ball, regardless.

Elsewhere on the show, the two staged their own catalogue photo shoot, replicating some of their model photos they’ve seen in catalogues. That includes “inexplicably laughing at takeout,” “being a sore loser on family game night,” and “waking up hungover after a crazy night.”

Perhaps even more surprising is the fact that Barrymore apparently gets really “excited” when catalogues arrive at her home.

Related content:

The Tonight Show (TV Show)

  • TV Show
  • In Season
  • NBC