This week, the celebrity in question was Pine, the show was Jimmy Kimmel Live, and the song was Vanilla Ice’s “Ice, Ice Baby.”
Pine should’ve seen it coming — he probably did — when Kimmel asked him about the first song he remembered knowing completely. “It’s not a bad song,” the I Am the Night actor said. So he worked a pen as a pretend microphone and, with help from Kimmel’s band, dropped the first verse.
It was no John Oliver screaming at the top of his lungs to Kelly Clarkson’s “Since U Been Gone,” but Pine’s 11-year-old self would be proud.
Watch the video above around the 5:41 mark.