Few things start a good-natured argument among friends like deciding who is the Sporty Spice or Dorothy or Justin Timberlake of the group.
But that’s what we asked Queer Eye’s Fab 5 — Bobby Berk, Karamo Brown, Tan France, Antoni Porowski, and Jonathan Van Ness — to do at our Summer Preview cover shoot.
Among the other famous Fab 5s up for debate: NSYNC; the Spice Girls; the casts of Stranger Things (Van Ness is all about being Winona Ryder… but at the SAG Awards) and The Wizard of Oz (Toto included — and there’s a fight about who gets to be the dog — while Brown is all about the Scarecrow, but for a very specific reason); musical divas (Van Ness is not happy when France suggests replacing one legend); and in a very special category, the ingredients of Porowski’s guacamole.
Watch the video above for all the ensuing hilarity. Queer Eye season 2 — which includes the series’ first female and trans male subjects — debuts June 15 on Netflix.