Tia is asking the question on all of our minds.

On Sunday, it’s time for Arie’s turn in the hot seat during The Bachelor‘s “Women Tell All” special, in which Arie will come face-to-face with the women he’s sent home on his journey to find love. And one of those women has a very specific question.

During last week’s rose ceremony, Bachelor fans watched as Arie doubted his feelings for Kendall before ultimately deciding to keep Kendall and send fan-favorite Tia home. And now, Tia wants answers. EW has an exclusive sneak peek at the “Women Tell All,” in which Tia very pointedly asks Arie why he would send her home if he was unsure about his relationship with Kendall.

Now, let’s see how he talks himself out of this one…

The “Women Tell All” special airs Sunday at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.

Episode Recaps