We asked the cast of Survivor: Ghost Island (premiering Feb. 28 on CBS) to reveal their favorite players ever and you can see those responses here. But that was easy. Little did the new cast members know they were also facing their first big twist of the season. That’s because as soon as they told us their favorite players, we asked them a question far more diabolical: Who is your least favorite player ever?
Seeing as how these folks were going to have to be talking smack about each other for 39 days — if they were lucky — we figured we’d get them warmed up by talking smack about a former contestant first. So let the smack talk begin!
Check out the video above to see which former Survivors got roasted out in the Fijian sun by the new cast.