Finding “the one” is hard. We get it. With so many television shows out there — both new and returning — how are you supposed to find the show that will make you feel whole? The one that will be your partner through thick and thin. The one that will never, ever betray you.

Well, we can’t promise all that, but we can promise that there are plenty of fish in the fictional sea, and to help you find your perfect match, EW gathered some of fall TV’s biggest stars to help you decide which show should win your heart… at least this year.

Watch the video above to learn how to find your perfect fall TV match.

(Script by Samantha Highfill and Kristen Harding)