The Voice recap: Live Semifinal Eliminations
The singers are in for the toughest cuts of the season, and only the magic of Dolly Parton can ease the blow
It’s a bloodbath tonight on The Voice, as more than half of the Top Nine are suddenly cut from the season. Who was culled, and who made it through to next week’s finale? The results are not exactly what you’d expect.
Before The Voice can really dive into the meat of the episode, season 3 winner Cassadee Pope opens the show with her song “I Am Invincible.” Season 9 hopefuls, behold your future. Cassadee doesn’t have Jordan’s range or Emily Ann’s gumption, but she does have an ease on stage that only comes with experience. She shows off more personality than most of the current contestants — but maybe she’s only free to do so now that there’s no pressure on her. That spunk keeps the performance from fading into a total snoozefest, but I’m eager to find out who our finalists are, and I have little time to listen to anyone who’s not in the Top Nine.
Except, of course, for Dolly Parton. Dolly, I would listen to you talk for hours about growing up in the Smoky Mountains with your 11 brothers and sisters. Whether she’s singing her classic songs that will outlive us all or just chatting it up with Carson, this lady knows how to tell a story. The veteran performer meets with the remaining nine contestants, who are visibly excited to be granted a private face-to-face (Emily Ann can barely keep her eyes in her head). She share a little advice (or “information,” as she puts it), and then we’re off to hear who’s the first safe singer of the night.
No surprise, it’s Jordan Smith. Jordan’s version of “Somebody to Love” went all the way to the No. 1 spot on iTunes last night, beating out Adele — a serious accomplishment. In fact, every performer but Shelby Brown made it into the iTunes Top 10, meaning it’s still a toss up over who will claim those final three spots in the finale. We learn who the next safe singer is right away: Emily Ann Roberts will also be sticking around.
That’s cool and all, but now it’s time for Dolly to perform. She sings her ‘70s hit “Coat of Many Colors” (it’s a tie-in to a TV movie of the same name NBC is putting on this week, based on her childhood). There is so much lure and legend surrounding Dolly Parton that it’s surprising to find how straightforward and real she is after so many years in the public eye. She’s nearly 70, and she can’t belt out all the notes like she used to, but she still gives a warm, gripping performance. Dolly is such a fun, sprightly figure, she could recite the phone book and I’d still be delighted to hear her. Thankfully, “Coat of Many Colors” is a much better story than the phone book.
WANT MORE? Keep up with all the latest from last night’s television by subscribing to our newsletter. Head here for more details.
Once she heads off stage, Carson announces the third safe performer who’s heading to the finale: Barrett Baber made it through. Then Carson reveals which three of the six remaining artists will sing for the Instant Save and which three will leave the show right now. (I’m relieved that all six won’t be made to perform because splitting the Instant Save six ways could have led to some very awkward results.) The three singers who will sing for their lives are Jeffery Austin, Madi Davis, and Zach Seabaugh. Braiden Sunshine, Shelby Brown, and Amy Vachal’s journeys all end here. I’m shocked Amy didn’t make it into the top six this week, especially after placing so highly the past few episodes.
NEXT: The choice is obvious
The Instant Save performances leave no doubt as to which artist should move on to next week’s finale. First up, we get a chastened, emotional version of Zach performing what could be his final go-around. He chooses Tim McGraw’s “Live Like You Were Dying.” It’s a perfectly serviceable rendition but nothing worthy of a finale slot on The Voice. He doesn’t delve as deep into his range as I wish, and his notes sound weaker than we’ve heard from him in a while. With nary a pelvic thrust in sight, I don’t see this ending well for him.
Next, Madi sings “Don’t Dream It’s Over” by Crowded House. Like Zach, her performance also feels like a weaker version of a singer I’ve seen some spectacular moments from on this show. Never the best at enunciation, “Don’t Dream It’s Over” moves too fast for Madi to show off that yodeling tone she so excels at. She also sounds off-key, and she strains to hit her runs.
Finally, Jeffery takes the stage to bring this party to its end. From the very first line, he blows Zach and Madi out of the water. Jeffery doesn’t just sing Foy Vance’s “Make It Rain.” He grabs this song by the throat and squeezes out every last drop of passion. He sounds gritty and electric and delivers stronger notes than at any other point this season. By the end, Adam is standing alongside Gwen, making his finale vote clear (with one team member already secure and two out of the running, he’s the only coach free to pick a favorite). If either of the other two singers makes it through over Jeffery, it won’t be because they gave a better performance.
Thankfully, that’s an alternate reality we don’t have to experience. During the commercial break, Jeffery’s vote tally is way ahead of Zach’s and Madi’s, and when we return, Carson quickly declares him the fourth finalist. Next week’s episode just got a whole lot more interesting.
- There were more votes cast last night than during any other voting period in Voice history. I think it’s safe to assume this show still has several seasons in its future
- When he was saying farewell to Zach, Blake assured him that, though this may be the end of his run on the show, it’s not the end of their friendship. Blake seems to take care of his team after the season’s over, and that’s why Team Blake alums are more successful than others