Four artists -- two from Team Adam and two from Team Cee Lo -- get the boot in week 2 of elimination rounds

By Marc Snetiker
Updated April 14, 2015 at 11:21 PM EDT
Credit: Lewis Jacobs/NBC
S2 E13
  • TV Show
  • NBC

Remember that time Christina Aguilera forgot Tony Vincent’s name after seven weeks of knowing him? (Can I get an all-caps LOL?) Because I certainly remember, and I’m certain that poor Tony won’t forget it anytime soon, since “Tony, right? That’s your name, Tony?” was the last thing Christina said to him before he got the boot on tonight’s episode. Tough exit!

Last night featured four more eliminations on The Voice, and for what it’s worth, I’d wager that most of them were pretty unsurprising. But my job is not simply to be a dispensary of adjectives when it comes time to analyze the results. Nay, I will relay the events of the night, beginning with a bubbly, colorful performance by pop siren Jessie J (singing “Domino”).

The performance might have been flawless were it not for Team Christina randomly joining J onstage and swaying awkwardly in the background, harmonizing ever so quietly. Honestly, if Carson Daly hadn’t announced that Jermaine Paul, Chris Mann, Lindsey Pavao and Jesse Campbell would be performing alongside the Brit gumdrop, I would have been seriously confused as to the ragtag array of back-up dancers.

And on to the first elimination we go! It’s Team Adam up first, and Coach Levine alerts us that “this is the part of the process that’s so unnatural and strange,” and that ultimately the singers have to remember that they’re playing a game. A Hunger Game? A Game of Thrones? Clue? I’m boggled.

Who did America vote to save from Team Adam? In no particular order (which I don’t buy for a second!), the first singer to be caressed by the sweet, intricate ropes of a metaphorical safety net is Indian Zooey Deschanel Mathai, who was a shoe-in, of course. The second to be saved: Mouseketeer Tony Lucca, whose large fan base no doubt voted him through despite a less than magical performance on Monday (did you see what I did there? Magical!). Finally, Carson bestowed blissful American salvation upon monosyllabic bowtie model Pip, who looked utterly scared to death.

That left Kim “Chaka Kahn” Yarbrough, Katrina “Mold Story” Parker and Karla “Karla” Davis in the bottom three, ready to sing for their lives after a handful of commercial breaks (sadly, there was no repeat appearance of Lisa Rinna’s ‘Depends’ commercial).

Over on Team Cee Lo, the first person to be voted through by America was Juliet Simms, who gave last night’s strongest female performance. Really, I say strongest because her rendition of “Roxanne” literally had biceps (not literally, though). The second save was Jamar Rogers, whose mother’s gracious reaction far outshone his own. And rounding out the three was yet another J: James Massone, who enthusiastically repeated “Yeah, man!” as he scurried offstage to go fix a car.

Before we get on to the last-chance performances, I have to crown tonight’s winner of Most Awkward: “Dip It Low” chanteuse Christina Milian, who invited us into the Sprint social media lounge and made us want to never tweet again. As if a silent room full of people on their phones isn’t awkward enough, Christina asked Tony Lucca and Pip their opinions on who Adam should save. Because that’s not an uncomfortable question.

NEXT: “Sing! Sing, for your life!”

Kim Yarbrough kicks off the sing-for-your-life segment with Jennifer Hudson’s “Spotlight,” which has a vintage quality to it that suits Kim’s voice far better than that song she sang Monday night by that wacky youthful troublemaker Adele.

Karla Davis followed with a country-lite rendition of “I Can’t Make You Love Me,” which seemed like a remarkably ironic song to sing to America after she proved last night that she could not, in fact, make you love her. (A shout-out to one of our live blog friends, who astutely pointed out, “I think she is incapable of performing without boots.”)

After another Lisa Rinna-less commercial break, Katrina Parker sang “Don’t Speak,” and if you thought she looked like Adele last night, then tonight… you probably thought she looked like Adele again. Tackling the Adele bun on Monday and the big poof on Tuesday, what’s even left?!

Ultimately, Adam (backed by all three coaches) opted to keep Katrina in the show. Blake praised Katrina’s sense of urgency, which I guess is relatively important for a last-chance song, while Christina elegantly reminded us all that having to send someone home is “sucky.” Nevertheless, Kim and Karla were sent home as Katrina and Adam were sent to an even worse place: the Sprint Awkwardness Lounge, which was made even more awkward by Adam pointing out just how awkward it was.

Back to the stage. Team Cee Lo’s bottom three were led by Tony “That’s your name, Tony?” Vincent, who sang “Sweet Dreams (Are Made of This)” and stared directly into the camera like he was casting a curse on the viewing public. (Another live blog gem: “Voldemort does Eurythmics!”) After Tony, Cheesa managed to actually sing for her life, belting out “All By Myself” with absolutely no irony whatsoever.

And then there’s Erin Martin, arguably the electric eel in a zoo of adorable singing puppies. Remarkably, this performance marked the last time we’ll ever have to hear her sing, and since she could sense my fear, she made it her worst performance yet. Nothing about her rendition of “Your Song” was good, period, but I did find myself amused at the sheer irony of Erin Martin singing the lyric, “My gift is my song.”

Not a moment too soon, Cee Lo made his save — for Cheesa — and Erin and Tony became the seventh and eighth singers eliminated from the show.

What did you think of the episode? Were the right people sent home? Did Cee Lo and Adam make the right saves? And how freaking awkward was the Sprint social lounge!?

Episode Recaps

The Voice

A rotating chair-full of judges search for the next great superstar singer on this NBC reality show.

  • TV Show
  • 15
  • 388
  • NBC