Etta James sang, Demi Lovato screeched, Tom slightly winced, ''Le Reve'' lunged, and finally, David Alan Grier waltzed out of the competition

By Annie Barrett
Updated April 08, 2009 at 04:00 PM EDT
Dancing With the Stars, David Alan Grier
Credit: Craig Sjodin/ABC

Despite a much-improved dance-off performance, higher judges’ scores, and the glaring fact that he’s a much better dancer than most of the remaining men, David Alan Grier left the Dancing With the Stars ballroom last night in what we can only hope was a slow shuffle peppered with his signature ”peeing dog”-style high kicks and arabesques. I never quite warmed up to the guy in the past few weeks — I’ve enjoyed his comedic acting whenever I’ve seen it, but his stern, non-effusive manner in real life was simply not a good fit for this bright and shiny show. Talent-wise, Chuck, Steve-O, or DAG’s dance-off opponent Lawrence Taylor should have gone home first, but to be honest I’m not surprised it was DAG instead. I think he (unintentionally) made people uncomfortable. I’m sad for the self-proclaimed ”old, wet food stamp” of the season, because he was clearly one of the hardest-working contestants. Looking forward, we can only hope that DAG’s elimination will go down in history as The Night The Powers That Be Finally Realized The Dreaded Dance-Off Was So…Incredibly…Abysmally…POINTLESS!

Aggghhh! So much tension last night! Backstage with Samantha right after their paso doble, Lawrence took huge, ambiguous pauses before straining to answer two questions in the upbeat, positive way he’s supposed to on live TV. I’m guessing he acted so weird right then because he thought (as I did) that his Tuesday night performance was no better (not even any different, really) than Monday’s, and that the judges only raved about it for dramatic effect. Put simply, he felt played. At this point, I think LT is supremely fed up with the contrast between a grueling week of dance practice and the meager payoff of a set of judges’ comments that basically amount to ”meh” each week. Of course, that’s the name of the game on DWTS, especially if you’re not that talented and stick around anyway due to the popular vote. He kept himself in check this week, but LT might snap pretty soon — that is, if the normally serene Lady Legwarmer doesn’t snap first. LT seems like he’s dying to fly back to Florida to play golf…and engage in possible lap dances with his buddies. Golf never demands that he don a bolero (though his lap-dance customers might splurge for that, as an ”upgrade”). The Giant just misses his golf! This probably explains his watery eyes (!!!) during the final group hug.

The legendary Etta James showed up to sing a very different version of ”At Last” than the one we’re used to hearing in restaurants (or, in my case, on a playlist entitled ”Calm The **** Down”). You may recall how not happy Etta was that Beyoncé had performed her signature song for President and First Lady Obama at ABC’s Neighborhood Ball in January. (Ever the bedazzled patriot, I went ahead and critiqued the First Couple’s inaugural waltz as if they were DWTS contestants in this ridiculous PopWatch item. Looking back, the feathers on Michelle’s gown significantly upped her performance value.) Accompanying the seated Etta were Maks and Karina, the recently inaugurated First Couple of Dancing With the Stars. Sorry, Alec/Edyta and Jonathan/Anna, but work on becoming a bit more Flashy/Polarizing and you’ll all have a decent shot at the next term! Some of Maks and Karina’s lifts were incredible, especially the ”Allow me to introduce my fianceé’s crotch to your face” one they did early in the dance for one lucky corner of the crowd. I also loved how excited Samantha was to announce that Etta was performing ”live!” At first I had love/hate issues with Sam’s screechingly pink Ballroom Barbie gown, but after a few lingering shots of her, I realized the color perfectly matched the rest of the crazy set, not to mention she looked amazing in that thing. Could anyone else not stop staring at her lightly beaded ”belt”?

Speaking of things that are screeching, Disney darling Demi Lovato, a.k.a. the teenager my colleague Michael Slezak once referred to as ”something called a Demi Lovato” as if she were a gross side dish he refused to let the rest of his higher-quality food touch, murdered our ears with a half-growling, half-caterwauling performance of something called ”La La Land.” Luckily, Benji Schwimmer and Tori Smith were in da ballroom to distract from the audio element of this segment with an outpour of horrifying tongue wags from Benji and the giant pink bow on Tori’s butt. Perhaps that costume was a ”subtle” nod to this tragic Ugly Betty outfit from early March. At least none of ”our pros” had to dance to this monstrosity — in fact, I’ll put a positive spin on this and say the frantic nature of both song and dance complemented each other quite nicely. Don’t put nicely in quotes. Don’t put nicely in quotes. Did I say nicely? I meant ”nicely.” If you get the chance, go back and watch the way poor Tom slightly winced right after delivering the awesome news that ”Tickets for Demi’s summer tour go on sale April 25th.”

NEXT PAGE: Your nominees for Hidden Gems of the Week!

D’oh! Macy’s Stars of Dance! You’re back. This week’s segment sponsored by a department store featured the cast of Le Reve, the Vegas show that Maks helped choreograph when he sat out during season 6. I mistakenly expected the tripped-out DWTS lighting department to have created an ”as seen in our warped version of reality” depiction of water for the floor, but we got a decent idea of what goes on in Le Reve even without any special effects. Some very impressive competitive-cheerleading-esque ”throws” in there, though I think I saw DANCMSTR whisper to Bruno that all the flips and leaps and general ”messin’ about” struck him as ”a bit much.” It should come as no surprise that my favorite performers of this segment were the bald-save-for-a-squiggle men swathed from the ribs down in billowing red satin. I’m looking forward to these guys appearing in some of my upcoming non-sexual DWTS fantasies (my waking reves, if you will) as the once-weekly special cleaning crew. They’ll emerge at midnight after the Tuesday shows and ”sweep the floor” one full-twisting lunge at a time.

Hidden Gem of the Week When Steve-O finished his waltz and Wee Man was shown clapping, there was a Wee Girl behind him! This week’s HGOTW has been brought to you by April (”I had to do a double take to make sure that was actually a kid and not maybe his ‘wee girlfriend’), and was eagerly endorsed by Josh and Skinny.

But wait! The runner-up nominations were too good not to spend a half hour hunting for on’s full episode player. Behold them in all their sparkly glory!

Pictured: Bruno’s ”awesome sissy moment,” whining ”Ow!” to DANCMSTR after smashing his fist into the desk (submitted by DC and Beatrice), Lacey ”clapping like she just did her nails” backstage (submitted by quirkie), the magenta-tinted ”brunette woman yawning while Tom teased the results show” (submitted by twinmom), and Tony and the costume department’s sequined shout-out to Tony’s homeland, Albania (submitted by Sean). I always thought ”Say It With Sequins” was a much better modus operandi than ”Say It With Flowers.” This show is constantly reaffirming my most important beliefs.

Happy with last night’s elimination, DANCMSTRS, or did it annoy you as much as it annoyed LT? Comment about it!

Episode Recaps


Dancing With the Stars

  • TV Show
  • 28
  • ABC