Big Brother: Over the Top recap: Season 1, Episode 5
If you’ve ever seen the movie Bad News Bears, or even that silly 2006 comedy The Benchwarmers (what can I say? I’m watching the World Series and I’ve got baseball on the mind), you probably understand why it’s fun to root for the underdog.
The underdogs are the ones with heart, the ones who get knocked down repeatedly but always get back up again. They’re lovable losers, because even though they never seem to come out on top, they endear themselves to you anyway.
Which is what makes this season of Big Brother: Over the Top so frustrating — the lovable losers really aren’t so lovable. In fact, they’re borderline unbearable. But we’ll get to that in a sec.
For now, in this week’s BB: OTT, we head back to the house just before Neeley’s eviction to find Scott delivering a campaign spiel to Jason. First of all, Jason and Neeley are BFFs, so I don’t see what he thinks he’s going to accomplish here; secondly, Scott is the ONLY person in the entire house who’s not in an alliance, so I can’t see his offer for “the next best thing” to a final three going very far with Jason.
After the eviction, Shelby celebrates in the diary room by calling the Late Night Jamboree a bunch of “hypocridiots.” She quickly rises in the ranks of my all-time favorite Big Brother players thanks to that hilarious portmanteau. Well done, Shelby.
Kryssie is incredibly upset, as is to be expected, but never fear — Justin is here! Justin and his mustache console a crying Kryssie, and he assures her he’ll protect her from Scott. (Again, Scott is the only player in the house not part of an alliance. I am confused why everyone is so afraid of someone with zero power). But just as he finishes his talk with her, he goes to celebrate with Scott and the Ball-Smashers! Justin is totally playing both sides and no one seems to notice and/or care, so that’s cool for him, I guess.
Danielle continues to (understandably) be upset by Scott’s constant bullying, and while Scott is definitely being a jerk, the whole thing is so juvenile I tune out most of it. Also, I like when Kryssie says things like, “It’s just a game to them!” Yes, Kryssie, it is just a game — to everyone! That’s what you signed up for! It’s getting annoying to watch people who are so clearly having such a miserable time in the house. Like, stop complaining for five minutes and enjoy your free vacation.
Danielle quickly makes it known to her alliance she doesn’t want to nominate Scott. Huh? Once she explains her reasons, though, it makes sense. He’s pretty much useless, so who cares if he sticks around for another week? The only chance the Late Night Jamboree has to avoid eviction the next few weeks is to take down the Ball-Smashers. They toss around the idea of trying to evict Alex this week, and decide that out of all the girls, it’d be easiest to get Whitney on their side.
With Jason certain Danielle is gunning for Alex, he tells Scott he can rest easy knowing he’s most likely safe, hoping to get on Scott’s good side in case he stays another week. I’m convinced Big Brother has placed Scott into his own alliance known as The Debt Collector, because literally no one else is referred to by their occupation as often as he is.
NEXT: If you’re not Whit us, you’re against us…
Soon, America’s Care Package arrives and it’s for Shelby. On eviction night, she gets to eliminate three eviction votes of her choice, which could be a pretty big deal since only three Late Night Jamboree members are eligible to vote.
With America having made its pro-Ball-Smashers voice pretty clear, Danielle is very upset at first. But then she’s just like, “Suck it, America, I’m going to do whatever I want whether you like it or not.” She decides her target for the week should be Morgan so she can’t get a future care package, which is some pretty smart thinking on her part.
Morgan and Alex both make a point of visiting Danielle in the HOH room and suggesting the idea of teaming up in the future. The house being split down the middle can’t last that much longer. This gets Danielle rethinking her target, since she knows both Alex and Morgan would be good people to have on her side. She decides to nominate Whitney and Shelby, and Scott joins them on the block as America’s nominee.
Now here’s where things start to get a little weird. After talking with Danielle and Justin, Whitney pretty much agrees to do whatever they want, so long as it means she gets to stay another week. She’s essentially playing both sides, which is fine…or would be fine, if she wasn’t so terrible at being sneaky! Playing both sides only works if nobody knows. So when Whitney chooses Justin over her alliance members to play for her in the veto competition, the girls realize right away that something is up. Like, come on, Whitney, did you really not think they’d realize choosing Justin was a strange move?
To blow her cover even further, Danielle wins the veto in a hilarious haunted-house competition — that includes Scott screaming like a little girl — and proceeds to TAKE WHITNEY OFF THE BLOCK. Her reasoning makes even less sense: She takes down Whitney puts up Morgan so they’re able to control Whitney’s vote and get Scott out. Huh? In what world was Morgan ever going to vote out Shelby or Whitney over Scott? If Whitney was up on the block as a pawn anyway, what was the point of swapping her out with Morgan? I’m not sure if it’s the excessive amount of Halloween candy I’ve consumed in the last 24 hours or if these people are just dumb, but either way, my brain hurts and I’m confused. I guess maybe they did it to throw Whitney a bone and show her they could be loyal to her… But still, it was odd to see them team up so publicly for what seemed like no reason.
As to be expected, Alex, Shelby, and Morgan pick up on Whitney’s shifting allegiances quickly and talk about gunning for her in the coming weeks.
At the eviction ceremony, Alex and Whitney vote to evict Scott, and their two votes make it official. For all of his misguided strategies, Scott really loved the game and it made him a fun one to watch. It’s been real, Scott, and I have no doubt I’ll miss how you clap with your hands above your head whenever you get excited. Debt Collector, out.