Ryan Reynolds might be a Golden Globe-nominated actor, but his Christmas cookie-making skills probably still need a bit of work. (Nobody’s perfect, right?)

Reynolds’ wife, Blake Lively, poked fun at the actor in a post on Instagram, showing off the Deadpool star’s not-quite-stellar creations.

“@vancityreynolds made some Christmas cookies…,” Lively captioned the photo, adding, “He’s verrry handsome though.”

Reynolds, however, stands by his handiwork. “I wanted to be the first person to bake Christmas cookies using only a hammer,” he commented on the post.

Reynolds and Lively, who costarred in 2011’s Green Lantern, were married in 2012 and have two daughters. This also isn’t the first time they’ve used Instagram to have a little fun with one another — just take a look at how they celebrated their birthdays.