'X Factor': Top 4's Best/Worst Performances

Annie Barrett picks top hit/biggest miss for Marcus Canty, Chris Rene, Melanie Amaro, and Josh Krajcik
By Annie Barrett
Updated December 13, 2011 at 11:00 PM EST

1 of 8

MARCUS CANTY: BEST ''A Song for You''

Ray Mickshaw/Fox

I probably should have picked one of his more upbeat sparkle explosions for his best — those, like Rock Week's ''Piece of My Heart,'' have added a lot of visual performance quality to the season. But vocally Marcus sounded strongest on Top 5 night's Contestant's Choice number.

Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 8

MARCUS CANTY: WORST ''A Song for Mama''

Ray Mickshaw/FOX

Yes, I cried when he reached out for his mom to save her from the Smoke Monster and tell her she was the queen of his heart. But boy sounded a mess!

3 of 8

CHRIS RENE: BEST ''Where Do We Go From Here?''

Ray Mickshaw/Fox

Chris Rene's original tune was simple, unpretentious, and exactly what he needed to seem legit as a member of the Top 4. With his stripped-down staging and acoustic guitar, it was like watching an entirely different contestant.

Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

4 of 8

CHRIS RENE: WORST ''I'll Be There''

Ray Mickshaw/Fox

With the exception of his other original track (''Young Homie''), most of Chris' early performances blend together for me. But I do remember ''I'll Be There'' as one of the weakest Jackson Night numbers. Blanket was certainly not impressed.

Advertisement

5 of 8

MELANIE AMARO: BEST ''World's Greatest''

Ray Mickshaw/FOX

Melanie's vocals are nearly flawless each week, but ''World's Greatest,'' during the Thanksgiving episode, showed the most raw feeling from her — and an outpour of joy. In the few weeks since then, her performances have almost seemed angry.

6 of 8

MELANIE AMARO: WORST ''Someone Like You''

Ray Mickshaw/Fox

Having Melanie sing a wildly popular but very slow and mournful Adele single remixed as a dance hit was a bit bizarre. I'm not sure we can count it as a valiant effort for her to go upbeat. (Of course, she hit all of the notes anyway.)

Advertisement
Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

7 of 8

JOSH KRAJCIK: BEST ''Wild Horses''

Ray Mickshaw/Fox

I love to see a contestant play the piano, and this song from Josh delivered an emotional impact on par with my other favorite performance of his: ''First Time Ever I Saw Your Face'' at the judges' homes.

Advertisement
Advertisement

8 of 8

JOSH KRAJCIK: WORST ''We Found Love''

Ray Mickshaw/Fox

''Dance Music Hits'' and ''Josh Krajcik'' don't belong in the same sentence, but couldn't his mentor Nicole have let him branch out a bit here? (Official Rihanna Presents The X Factor rulebook says nope, sorry!)

Advertisement
Replay gallery

Share the Gallery

Up Next