Tony Awards 2011: Best/Worst Style

The actress was a shining combination of movie star grace and Broadway dazzle in this sparkling gown by Elie Saab. A+

The Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark star shined in a luminous tea-length Reem Acra dress gown. A

The Best Actress nominee may not have taken home a trophy, but her flawless Romona Keveza one-shoulder gown was certainly award-worthy. A-

Daniel Radcliffe may be the big celebrity in How to Succeed in Business, but on the red carpet, his co-star — dressed in a mermaid-style Edition by Georges Chakra gown — was front and center. B+

The Normal Heart star — and best featured actress winner! — was the picture of grace in a long-sleeved number by L'Wren Scott. B+

It didn't set off any fashion alarms, but the CSI star's halter gown was a simple yet sexy choice. B

Her white halter and flower accessory may have lent a summery touch to the sea of darker dresses, but the ill-paired black shoes were too jarring to let us soak it in. B-

The stage star earned brownie points for the ravishing red color but lost almost all of them for the altogether disheveled ensemble. B-

Another victim of poor-shoe-choice syndrome, James sullied her perfectly pretty red strapless gown with her unfortunate footwear. B-

Light has achieved something much coveted in Hollywood — career longevity. But did she have to remind us of it with her Who's The Boss?-era 'do? C+

It can be exhausting to work the red carpets for as long as Shields has, but that doesn't make it okay to step out in bedroom sheets. C

If only Davis' sartorial choices — this time a brilliant fuchsia dress with ill-chosen accessories — were as solid as her acting ones? C-

We couldn't decide what was more offensive with Yelland's dress: the mullet cut or close relation to bridal wear. C-

Known for her logic-defying style, (see here and here), Goldberg reminded us once again that while habits may be her strong suit, red carpet fashion certainly is not. D

Despite her daughter's elegant look, former model Brinkley clearly mistook the Tonys for a Miss America Pageant. Alexa Ray Joel: A-; Christie Brinkley: F