That's Just Wrong!

Readers confess the very embarrassing snap judgments they've made about ''Idol,'' the Newlyweds, Harry Potter, ''Titanic,'' and more...

By EW Staff Updated March 01, 2007 at 09:00 PM EST

Skip gallery slides

1 of 18

1

Credit: Photofest

2 of 18

2

Credit: KELLY CLARKSON: K. Winter/FOX

3 of 18

3

Continued on next slide.

4 of 18

4

Credit: Mario Perez

5 of 18

5

Credit: Merie W. Wallace

6 of 18

6

Credit: Vivian Zink

Continued on next slide.

7 of 18

7

Credit: Superman Returns: Sony Pictures Imageworks

8 of 18

8

9 of 18

9

Credit: Kevin Fitzsimons

Continued on next slide.

10 of 18

10

Credit: Mariah Carey: Markus Klinko & Indrani

11 of 18

49. Randy Hickey

Credit: Paul Drinkwater

Sidekick to: Earl J. Hickey
My Name Is Earl (2005-09)

My Name Is Earl's title character has made a lot of mistakes, but keeping his brother by his side isn't one of them. With a childlike innocence and almost touching stupidity, Randy follows Earl on his quest for karmic redemption like a really, really dumb bulldog. He'll even give Earl a swirly if that means Earl can cross something off his list. And who can blame Randy if he's sometimes sidelined by a paralyzing fear of chickens? They do seem like nasty birds. —Tim Stack