Ranking every season of The Bachelorette

We look back — and judge — the drama of the past 13 seasons, the times true love prevailed… and failed.

Meredith was the first Bachelorette to be on a season of The Bachelor, this one led by Bob Guiney, who was, in turn, on a season of The Bachelorette (Trista Rehn). Got all that? Although her season wasn’t incredibly memorable — she ended up with Ian, in case you forgot —as only the second Bachelorette ever, she still holds a place in our hearts…. which is why we’re giving our final rose to her. —Dalene Rovenstine

Coming off Sean Lowe’s season of The Bachelor, Desiree was pitched as the nice girl. And she was. But nice only goes so far in terms of entertainment. Her one saving grace? All the drama surrounding Brooks Forester — her number one pick — who decided to leave the show, and somehow led to Desiree realizing that her true love, Chris Siegfried, was right in front of her the entire time. The two are now married and expecting their first child. —Samantha Highfill

A rare Bachelor Nation success story, Ashley Hebert made it down the aisle with the winner of her final rose. She met now-husband J.P. Rosenbaum on the seventh season of the show after getting her heart broken by Brad Womack on the 15th season of The Bachelor. She endured some tough blows when two men voluntarily quit her season, but it worked out in her favor in the end as she and Rosenbaum are still married and now have a child, nearly five years later. —Madeline Boardman

Before becoming the Bachelorette, DeAnna was a part of one of the most shocking Bachelor finales in history when Brad Womack sent both of his final two women home. Pappas then took her adorable accent to The Bachelorette, where she introduced the world to Jason Mesnick — who would go on to become the Bachelor. Sadly, not much else came out of her season, unless you count her failed relationship with that snowboarder. —Samantha Highfill

After being rejected by Nick Viall, Rachel faced more pressure than usual when she became the first black Bachelorette. But she handled it gracefully — even as she, unfortunately, had to deal with that whole Lee vs. Kenny scenario. Sadly though, her season wasn’t nearly as epic as many had hoped (especially if you were rooting for Peter). —Samantha Highfill

The third Bachelorette to look for love on air, Jen Schefft nabbed the gig after winning Andrew Firestone’s season of The Bachelor. While her love with Firestone didn’t last, she had quite the twist in store for her own season of The Bachelorette. She made it all the way to the final episode, only to turn down both Jerry Ferris and John Paul Merritt, her last two suitors. —Madeline Boardman

Andi Dorfman really had her pick of guys: a buff baseball player, a fit farmer, a pantspreneur, and a Nick Viall, among others. But these guys didn’t play well together and created a lot of drama outside of their relationships with Andi. As she might say, “Staaaahhhp.” It was entertaining for viewers at times, but also got a bit old. The constant fighting took a toll on the Bachelorette, and the news of Eric’s death put a more somber tone on the end of the season. —Dalene Rovenstine

After JoJo had her heart broken by Ben Higgins, it was impossible not to root for her to find happiness. (After all, she has a mother who drinks wine straight from the bottle!) Add in a passionate cowboy named Luke, a protein powder-loving Chad Bear, and, well, Jordan, and there was more than enough drama to go around… until there wasn’t. Sadly, JoJo’s season was either highly entertaining or borderline boring, but hey, at least she found love, right? —Samantha Highfill

Emily Maynard couldn’t quite catch a break when it came to ABC’s dating franchise, a turn that was unfortunate for the single mother but juicy for viewers. After losing her then-fiancé in a plane crash, Maynard went on the 15th season of The Bachelor and won, accepting a proposal from Brad Womack. They broke up soon after, and she got another shot at love as the eighth Bachelorette. She was in for heartbreak once more, however, as she chose Jef in the finale only to break up with him a few months later. —Madeline Boardman

After being turned down by Jason Mesnick, Jillian and her oh-so-relatable personality went on to become the Bachelorette. And thanks to her season, we were introduced to Kiptyn Locke, who would become a longtime Bachelor franchise favorite, and Jake Pavelka, who would become a much-debated Bachelor. But perhaps most importantly, we met the unforgettable Wes Hayden, the guitar playing bad boy America loved to hate. —Samantha Highfill

A textbook “guy’s girl,” Kaitlyn Bristowe became an early frontrunner on Chris Soules’ season of The Bachelor. While she was eventually edged out by Becca Tilley and Whitney Bischoff, she won the real prize when she became ABC’s 11th Bachelorette. She was a star for the ages: funny, entertaining, and as real as you can be with a dozen cameras on you at all times. While they have yet to walk down the aisle, Bristowe and her pick, Shawn Booth, are still engaged nearly a year after the season finale. —Madeline Boardman

The sixth Bachelorette almost never had her own season of the reality franchise: On Jake Pavelka’s season 14 (aka The Bachelor: On the Wings of Love), Ali made history by putting her career ahead of a man — gasp! She quit The Bachelor instead of her job… but then she wound up quitting anyway and becoming the Bachelorette. Thankfully for us she did, because her season offered up Justin “Rated R” Rego and Kasey Kahl. The images of Justin trying to flee the show while in a foot cast and Kasey being stranded on a glacier are some of the best of the series to date. And on top of all that, Ali and Robert made a pretty cute couple, even if it wasn’t forever. —Dalene Rovenstine

There’s nothing better than watching a true love story, and from day one, Trista and Ryan were just that. The catch? Being so invested in the fate of the first Bachelorette and the sensitive firefighter with a love of poetry made the finale even more of a nail-biter than usual. Because as sure as you were that true love would prevail, the slightest chance it could fail was more than enough to make you sweat. But in the end, destiny won out, and Ryan got down on one knee. Years later, they’re still the most successful couple in Bachelor/Bachelorette history. —Samantha Highfill