Skip to content

Top Navigation

EW.com EW.com
    • All TV
    • TV Reviews
    • TV Reunions
    • Recaps
    • What to Watch
    • Winter TV
    • Comedy
    • Crime
    • Drama
    • Family
    • Horror
    • Reality
    • Sci-fi
    • Thriller
    • All Movies
    • Movie Reviews
    • Trailers
    • Film Festivals
    • Movie Reunions
    • Movie Previews
    • All Music
    • Music Reviews
    • All What to Watch
    • What to Watch Podcast Episodes
    • TV Reviews
    • Movie Reviews
    • All BINGE
    • EW's Binge Podcast Episodes
    • Recaps
    • Survivor
    • This is Us
    • RuPaul's Drag Race
    • Stranger Things
    • The Boys
    • The Blacklist
    • The Walking Dead
    • Better Call Saul
    • All The Awardist
    • The Awardist Podcast Episodes
    • Oscars
    • Emmys
    • Golden Globes
    • SAG Awards
    • Grammys
    • Tony Awards
    • All Books
    • Book Reviews
    • Author Interviews
    • All Theater
    • Theater Reviews
  • Podcasts
  • Gaming
    • All Events
    • Comic-Con
  • Celebrity
  • Streaming

Profile Menu

Your Profile

Account

  • Join Now
  • Email Preferences
  • Newsletter
  • Manage Your Subscription this link opens in a new tab
  • Give a Gift Subscription this link opens in a new tab
  • Logout
Login
Subscribe

Explore EW.com

EW.com EW.com
  • Explore

    Explore

    • The 10 best songs of 2022

      The 10 best songs of 2022

      From disco-trap to deconstructed techno to Dolly-style country, we rank our favorite tracks this year. Read More
    • The 10 best movies of 2022 (and 5 worst)

      The 10 best movies of 2022 (and 5 worst)

      Let there be Mavericks, Bollywood magic, and a Cate Blanchett maestro on the loose. Read More
    • The true story of the g-strings and murders behind Welcome to Chippendales

      The true story of the g-strings and murders behind Welcome to Chippendales

      A look back at the crazy true story of Chippendales founder Somen "Steve" Banerjee and the murder and murder-for-hire plots at the center of the Hulu series. Read More
  • TV

    TV

    See All TV
    • TV Reviews
    • TV Reunions
    • Recaps
    • What to Watch
    • Winter TV
    • Comedy
    • Crime
    • Drama
    • Family
    • Horror
    • Reality
    • Sci-fi
    • Thriller
  • Movies

    Movies

    See All Movies
    • Movie Reviews
    • Trailers
    • Film Festivals
    • Movie Reunions
    • Movie Previews
  • Music

    Music

    See All Music
    • Music Reviews
  • What to Watch

    What to Watch

    See All What to Watch
    • What to Watch Podcast Episodes
    • TV Reviews
    • Movie Reviews
  • BINGE

    BINGE

    See All BINGE
    • EW's Binge Podcast Episodes
    • Recaps
    • Survivor
    • This is Us
    • RuPaul's Drag Race
    • Stranger Things
    • The Boys
    • The Blacklist
    • The Walking Dead
    • Better Call Saul
  • The Awardist

    The Awardist

    See All The Awardist
    • The Awardist Podcast Episodes
    • Oscars
    • Emmys
    • Golden Globes
    • SAG Awards
    • Grammys
    • Tony Awards
  • Books

    Books

    See All Books
    • Book Reviews
    • Author Interviews
  • Theater

    Theater

    See All Theater
    • Theater Reviews
  • Podcasts
  • Gaming
  • Events

    Events

    See All Events
    • Comic-Con
  • Celebrity
  • Streaming

Profile Menu

Subscribe this link opens in a new tab
Your Profile

Account

  • Join Now
  • Email Preferences
  • Newsletter
  • Manage Your Subscription this link opens in a new tab
  • Give a Gift Subscription this link opens in a new tab
  • Logout
Login
Sweepstakes

Follow Us

  1. Home
  2. Gallery
  3. 'American Idol': Our Advice for the Top 12 Finalists

'American Idol': Our Advice for the Top 12 Finalists

Big Mike's dance moves. Crystal's stoicism. Lacey's Boca-seniors chic. We look at what's working -- and what's not -- for season 9's finalists and suggest some songs to help them stick around till late May
By Michael Slezak Updated March 15, 2010 at 08:45 PM EDT
Skip gallery slides
FB

1 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

DIDI BENAMI

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: Her feathery warble is one of the most distinctive on the season 9 roster — think Megan Joy with a better understanding…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: Her feathery warble is one of the most distinctive on the season 9 roster — think Megan Joy with a better understanding of her instrument and without the consistent pitch problems. And when she chooses the right song (her semifinal ''Rhiannon,'' her Hollywood Week ''Terrified''), Didi sounds like a threat to this year's perceived front-runners.

WHAT'S OFF KEY: It'll take versatility and nerves of steel for Didi to survive 11 more weeks of wildly varied themes and intense scrutiny from the judges. If the frequently teary-eyed competitor's foray into deep-rooted soul (''Lean on Me'') is any indicator, she'll need to work on adapting disparate genres to suit her style. Plus, she cannot sing a ballad every week.

REQUEST LIST: Modest Mouse's ''Float On,'' Kate Bush's ''Wuthering Heights,'' Depeche Mode's ''Personal Jesus''

1 of 12

Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

LEE DEWYZE

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: The only male contestant in the Top 12 who's forged a straightforward rock persona — and his gruff, slightly nasal tone is…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: The only male contestant in the Top 12 who's forged a straightforward rock persona — and his gruff, slightly nasal tone is immediately identifiable, too. He's already got Simon in his corner, and he's not lacking in the looks department, either.

WHAT'S OFF KEY: Has had problems staying consistently in tune every time he's taken the Idol stage — and unless the Idol vocal coaches can help him improve his technique, he runs the risk of looking like a poor man's David Cook. Wouldn't hurt to see his song choices go a little more unexpected than Hinder or Snow Patrol, either.

REQUEST LIST: Big Country's ''In a Big Country,'' Yeah Yeah Yeah's ''Maps,'' Sheryl Crow's ''My Favorite Mistake''

2 of 12

3 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

KATIE STEVENS

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: As she showed in her audition and during Hollywood Week, Katie's got one of those big-ole voices that can take on everything…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: As she showed in her audition and during Hollywood Week, Katie's got one of those big-ole voices that can take on everything from jazz standards to modern pop — and keep tweens and grandmas speed-dialing in the process.

WHAT'S OFF KEY: Lackluster semifinal showings on ''Feeling Good,'' ''Put Your Records On,'' and ''Breakaway'' can't just be blamed on conflicting advice from the judges. Katie struggles to stay in tune when she's not powering through a glory note and has failed to infuse any kind of excitement or personality into her vocals to date. Triumph over Lilly Scott in a head-to-head semifinal elimination has made her an object of rage in certain Idol circles.

REQUEST LIST: Martika's ''Toy Soldiers,'' Natalie Imbruglia's ''Torn,'' Backstreet Boys' ''I Want It That Way''

3 of 12

Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

4 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

MICHAEL LYNCHE

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: Three weeks running, he's delivered the smoothest, strongest vocal on the men's side — his cover of Kate Bush's ''This Woman's Work''…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: Three weeks running, he's delivered the smoothest, strongest vocal on the men's side — his cover of Kate Bush's ''This Woman's Work'' moved Kara to tears, and proved he's got falsetto firepower in his arsenal, too. Willingness to tackle everything from Maroon 5 to James Brown, while actually working the stage, is another strategic plus.

WHAT'S OFF KEY: Incredibly hammy stage antics during solo and group numbers gives a somewhat inauthentic slant to his performances. Needs to dial back on the pointing and winking and shameless mugging for the cameras and focus on connecting to the songs he's singing. Oh, and if Big Mike decides to break out the guitar again, it'd be nice if he actually played it instead of treating it like a jaunty prop, as he did during ''This Love.''

REQUEST LIST: Prince's ''Diamonds and Pearls,'' Jody Watley's ''Looking for a New Love,'' Wyclef Jean's ''911''

4 of 12

Advertisement

5 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

SIOBHAN MAGNUS

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: The haunting, crystal clear voice she displayed on ''House of the Rising Sun'' and ''Wicked Game'' is the stuff that Idols are…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: The haunting, crystal clear voice she displayed on ''House of the Rising Sun'' and ''Wicked Game'' is the stuff that Idols are made of. Quirky interview snippets — she's also a glassblower! she once had a Mohawk! — have made her seem more human (and less tragic) than some of her robot-like competitors.

WHAT'S OFF KEY: How quirky is too quirky? Simon is already giving Siobhan the ''dark and unlikeable'' feedback that he heaped on Allison Iraheta in season 8. And amidst a background of guitar-slinging foes, Siobhan needs to be careful her arrangements don't veer toward karaoke, as her cover of ''Think'' did in week two of the semifinals.

REQUEST LIST: Lou Reed's ''Sweet Jane,'' David Bowie's ''Life on Mars,'' Sinead O'Connor's ''No Man's Woman''

5 of 12

6 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

ANDREW GARCIA

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: His witty, daring Hollywood Week rearrangement of ''Straight Up'' vaulted him to instant front-runner status — and he's got a big backlog…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: His witty, daring Hollywood Week rearrangement of ''Straight Up'' vaulted him to instant front-runner status — and he's got a big backlog of other crafty acoustic covers posted on YouTube.

WHAT'S OFF KEY: Subsequent semifinal performances of everything from Fallout Boy to Christina Aguilera have felt less organic — and contained more bum notes — than his landmark Paula Abdul cover. Needs to prove he's not a one-trick pony, and that he's actually got the vocal chops to compete with folks like Crystal, Siobhan, and Michael.

REQUEST LIST: Tom Petty's ''Don't Come Around Here No More,'' Nikka Costa's ''Like a Feather,'' Pebbles' ''Giving You the Benefit''

6 of 12

Advertisement
Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

7 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

LACEY BROWN

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: The appealingly lilting quaver she put to use on ''What a Wonderful World'' during Hell Week returned just in the nick of…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: The appealingly lilting quaver she put to use on ''What a Wonderful World'' during Hell Week returned just in the nick of time for her solid semifinal performance of Brandi Carlile's ''The Story.'' Is it too shallow to point out her crazy-gorgeous eyes?

WHAT'S OFF KEY: Brutally pitchy take on Fleetwood Mac's ''Landslide'' turned her bandwagon into a cliff of leaping lemmings, and recent admission to Ryan Seacrest that her vision is to make ''songs that evoke emotions'' doesn't exactly point her out as an artist with a strong point of view. Plus, her attraction to leopard, gold, and pink combos reads more ''Florida retirement community'' than ''future Idol champ.''

REQUEST LIST: TLC's ''Waterfalls,'' Olivia Newton John's ''Please Mr. Please,'' Semisonic's ''Closing Time''

7 of 12

Advertisement
Advertisement

8 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

AARON KELLY

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: His initial semifinal performance of ''Here Comes Goodbye,'' while far from flawless, proved he can tackle a glory note with the best…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: His initial semifinal performance of ''Here Comes Goodbye,'' while far from flawless, proved he can tackle a glory note with the best of 'em.

WHAT'S OFF KEY: It's hard to buy emotionally complex material from a dewy-eyed 16-year-old whose vocals contain precious little heft. Plus, Aaron's most recent song choices — ''My Girl'' and ''I'm Already There'' — were major missteps; the former sounded way too dated, the latter was far too big for Aaron's not-yet-Archuleta vocals.

REQUEST LIST: Madonna's ''The Power of Goodbye,'' Simon and Garfunkel's ''Homeward Bound,'' Jewel's ''Who Will Save Your Soul''

8 of 12

Advertisement

9 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

CRYSTAL BOWERSOX

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: From her audition to the end of the semifinals, MamaSox has yet to hit a bum note. Her ''Give Me One Reason''…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: From her audition to the end of the semifinals, MamaSox has yet to hit a bum note. Her ''Give Me One Reason'' sexed-up a Tracy Chapman gem, and her Gospel-tinged cover of ''Long as I Can See the Light'' (performed one day after a scary hospital stay) was devastating in its emotional impact and quiet authority.

WHAT'S OFF KEY: While Crystal's reliance on mid-tempo classic rock jams shows she's got a strong sense of who she is as an artist, she'll need to diversify her portfolio if she wants to make it all the way to the Nokia. She'd benefit greatly from the occasional detour into up-tempo jams — or country and blues-tinged ditties. Oh, and those grim-faced shenanigans on Top 12 announcement night had best be a one-time-only occurrence; the Idol nation prefers its champs to be happy — and grateful.

REQUEST LIST: Lauryn Hill's ''Ex-Factor,'' White Stripes' ''You Don't Know What Love Is (You Just Do As You're Told),'' Guns N' Roses' ''Paradise City''

9 of 12

Advertisement
Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

10 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

CASEY JAMES

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: His cover of Bryan Adams' ''Heaven,'' while not particularly inventive, was one of the season's cleanest and most connected performances on the…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: His cover of Bryan Adams' ''Heaven,'' while not particularly inventive, was one of the season's cleanest and most connected performances on the men's side. Casey also pulls off the rare feat of gently poking fun at the Idol machinery (check those goofy looks of panic during group performances) without seeming ungrateful or mocking.

WHAT'S OFF KEY: Choice of overused-on-Idol ''I Don't Want to Be'' showed why it's good for contestants to know their Idol history, while unremarkably competent ''You'll Think of Me'' had the distinct taste of eighth or ninth place. Unexpected song selections — inventively arranged — are his only chance to be a true contender.

REQUEST LIST: Everclear's ''I Will Buy You a New Life,'' Shania Twain's ''You're Still the One,'' the Bangles' ''In Your Room''

10 of 12

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

11 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

PAIGE MILES

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: Simon continues to beat the drum that she's one of the best female vocalists in the competition; semifinal cover of Kelly Clarkson's…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: Simon continues to beat the drum that she's one of the best female vocalists in the competition; semifinal cover of Kelly Clarkson's ''Walk Away'' was solid, if slightly derivative.

WHAT'S OFF KEY: Her Top 16 week cover of ''Smile'' was an absolute disaster, raising the question of whether or not she can handle the intense pressure of Idol's big stage. And while we applaud her choice of rock ditties over big diva ballads, she's going to have to iron out her pitch problems if she wants to convert that admiration into fandom.

REQUEST LIST: Dolly Parton's ''What a Heartache,'' Ohio Players' ''Love Rollercoaster,'' Jessie James' ''Wanted''

11 of 12

Advertisement
Advertisement

12 of 12

FB
Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message

TIM URBAN

American Idol | WHAT'S IN TUNE: After a nails-in-a-blender moment on One Republic's ''Apologize,'' his relative tunefulness on ''Come on Get Higher'' and ''Hallelujah'' was a welcome relief.…
Credit: Frank Micelotta/Fox

WHAT'S IN TUNE: After a nails-in-a-blender moment on One Republic's ''Apologize,'' his relative tunefulness on ''Come on Get Higher'' and ''Hallelujah'' was a welcome relief. Plus, Tim has handled his ''you don't deserve to be here'' critiques with relative grace and good humor.

WHAT'S OFF KEY: He's improving, sure, but even his best-rated performances are devoid of passion and originality. Plus, we haven't forgotten his mistreatment of a David Cook track during Hollywood Week.

REQUEST LIST: Amy Grant's ''I Will Remember You,'' Natasha Bedingfield's ''These Words,'' Jim Croce's ''Time in a Bottle''

12 of 12

Advertisement
Advertisement
Replay gallery

Share the Gallery

Pinterest Facebook

Up Next

By Michael Slezak

    Share the Gallery

    Pinterest Facebook
    Trending Videos
    Advertisement
    Skip slide summaries

    Everything in This Slideshow

    Advertisement

    View All

    1 of 12 DIDI BENAMI
    2 of 12 LEE DEWYZE
    3 of 12 KATIE STEVENS
    4 of 12 MICHAEL LYNCHE
    5 of 12 SIOBHAN MAGNUS
    6 of 12 ANDREW GARCIA
    7 of 12 LACEY BROWN
    8 of 12 AARON KELLY
    9 of 12 CRYSTAL BOWERSOX
    10 of 12 CASEY JAMES
    11 of 12 PAIGE MILES
    12 of 12 TIM URBAN

    Share & More

    Tweet Pinterest Email Send Text Message
    EW.com

    Magazines & More

    Learn More

    • Subscribe this link opens in a new tab
    • Advertise this link opens in a new tab
    • Content Licensing this link opens in a new tab
    • Accolades this link opens in a new tab

    Connect

    Subscribe to Our Newsletter
    Meredith© Copyright 2023 Meredith Corporation. Entertainment Weekly is a registered trademark of Meredith Corporation All Rights Reserved. Entertainment Weekly may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice. Privacy Policythis link opens in a new tab Terms of Servicethis link opens in a new tab Ad Choicesthis link opens in a new tab California Do Not Sellthis link opens a modal window Web Accessibilitythis link opens in a new tab
    © Copyright EW.com. All rights reserved. Printed from https://ew.com

    View image

    'American Idol': Our Advice for the Top 12 Finalists
    this link is to an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines.