19 Fall TV Shows: Ken Tucker Grades 'em

Ken Tucker's Watching TV every day for his blog; see his early-season assessments of ''Modern Family,'' ''Glee,'' ''FlashForward,'' and more of the season's newcomers, then add your own grades
By Ken Tucker
Updated October 08, 2009 at 08:00 PM EDT

1 of 19

THE JAY LENO SHOW

Credit: Justin Lubin/NBC

Well, the 10pm gamble may be paying off financially for NBC, but not creatively for Jay. D+

Advertisement
Advertisement

2 of 19

TRAUMA

Credit: Paul Drinkwater/NBC

Flaming out fast in the ratings, this is actually a solid, ER-style nighttime soap. B

3 of 19

ACCIDENTALLY ON PURPOSE

Credit: Eric McCandless/CBS

Poor Jenna Elfman, stuck playing pregnant with lousy punchlines. Prediction: won't make it to its third trimester. D

Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

4 of 19

THE GOOD WIFE

Credit: Jason Bell/CBS

The best new old-fashioned network drama. Julianna Margulies and Chris Noth are terrific. B+

Advertisement

5 of 19

THE FORGOTTEN

Credit: Richard Foreman/ABC

A.K.A., Another TV Show Everyone Will Forget Christian Slater Was In. If he's lucky. C-

6 of 19

MELROSE PLACE

Credit: Frank Ockenfels/The CW

Started out strong, and I still think Katie Cassidy does a great job as a combo hero/villain, but the soap is more watery every week. B-

Advertisement
Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

7 of 19

GLEE

Credit: Carin Baer/Fox

The freshest, most original new show of the season is getting a little repetitive (at least one pregnancy too many for the good of the show's pace; too many American Idol-inspired song choices). Still, really well-acted and ?performed. B+

Advertisement
Advertisement

8 of 19

MERCY

Credit: Myles Aronowitz/NBC

Maybe they were trying for some Grey's Anatomy sort of nighttime soap-plus-tart-drama. What they got was a loud, panting drag. C-

Advertisement

9 of 19

MODERN FAMILY

Credit: Bob D'Amico/ABC

Super-fine ensemble acting, with tightly knit subplots linking the three families. Also nearly as many jokes per second as 30 Rock. In short: the best new show of the season so far. A-

Advertisement
Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

10 of 19

COUGAR TOWN

Credit: Mitch Haddad/ABC

So much better than its pilot! Courtney Cox's earnest slapstick works beautifully. If only the dialogue was more consistently funny. B

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

11 of 19

HANK

Credit: Patrick Wymore/ABC

You never want to spend a half-hour feeling badly for its star, but that's what happens every time I see Kelsey Grammer squandered in this quiet dud. C

Advertisement
Advertisement

12 of 19

THE MIDDLE

Credit: Richard Foreman/ABC

Wacky in a confident way, sure of its tone of genial cynicism, The Middle radiates with the brightness of Patricia Heaton and her co-stars. B+

Advertisement
Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

13 of 19

EASTWICK

Credit: Robert Voets/ABC

Oh, dear. Who thought trying to play down the witchcraft and play up the sisterhood, leaving out the sense of irony, was a good idea? Only Rebecca Romijn manages to seem comfortable in her role. Which I'm not sure is a bad or good thing. C

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

14 of 19

FLASHFORWARD

Credit: Craig Sjodin/ ABC

I'm in for the whole season: The show is working out its why-did-everyone-black-out? premise with panache, and Joseph Fiennes and Sonya Walger comprise the season's most intriguing marriage. B+

Advertisement
Advertisement

15 of 19

COMMUNITY

Credit: Byron Cohen/NBC

Hmmm. The pilot was so funny, I was willing to forgive the second week's dip in quality. Now I'm worried that Joel McHale and Chevy Chase aren't being given material good enough for them to sell with their champion array of smirks and giggles. B-

Advertisement
Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

16 of 19

THE VAMPIRE DIARIES

Credit: Bob Mahoney/The CW

Proving you can't go wrong in today's market with vampires, Diaries isn't nearly as imaginative as True Blood, but it's not sticky-icky romantic, either. It'll do at least until the new Twilight sequel opens. B-

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

17 of 19

BROTHERS

Credit: Ray Mickshaw/Fox

It strives for both laughs and a positive message, but achieves neither. These two adult brothers (Michael Strahan and Daryl Mitchell) have no chemistry, and the result is a certain grim tone not desirable for a sitcom. D+

Advertisement
Advertisement

18 of 19

THREE RIVERS

Credit: John P. Filo/CBS

Like Simon Baker, Alex O'Laughlin seems destined to burn through a few dramas as the only charming attraction until he hits upon a success. This drab organ-donor drama is not the one. C

Advertisement
Advertisement
Continued on next slide.
Advertisement

19 of 19

THE CLEVELAND SHOW

Credit: Fox

Cleveland may not be crammed with jokes, but it has an irresistible central cartoon character, a middle-aged, middle-class guy who, except for the bears living next door, is more believable than a lot of live-action sitcoms. B

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Replay gallery

Share the Gallery

Up Next