This Is Us Emmy nomination revoked
'House of Cards' will take its place on the ballot
UPDATE: House of Cards will take the place of This Is Us on the Emmy ballot in the Outstanding Contemporary Costumes category after the time-hopping NBC drama had its nomination rescinded, EW has learned.
The additional nod, for costume designers Johanna Argan, Kemal Harris, Jessica Wenger, and Steffany Bernstein-Pratt, would up the Netflix series’ Emmy nomination count to seven categories. The Academy of Television Arts and Sciences declined to confirm the news, which was first reported by The Hollywood Reporter.
EARLIER: This Is Us continued its freshman streak of greatness with 11 Emmy nominations, but now the hit NBC show is reducing that count to an even 10.
EW has confirmed that the time-hopping, nonlinear drama has had one of its 11 nominations rescinded after the Academy of Television Arts and Sciences determined it did not meet the requirements to be eligible for a nomination in the Outstanding Contemporary Costumes category, as first reported by The Hollywood Reporter. A sixth replacement nominee will be added to the category, in which HBO’s Big Little Lies, Fox’s Empire, Netflix’s Grace and Frankie and Amazon’s Transparent remain.
To be eligible for consideration in the category, a show must submit an episode where at least 51 percent of the action takes place within the past 25 years. Though there are some This Is Us episodes that meet this requirement, the NBC submitted, season 1 finale “Moonshadow,” does not. The episode, initially earning nods for the work of costume designers Hala Bahmet, Marina Ray and Elinor Bardach, takes place primarily in the 1970s in a series of lengthy flashbacks that highlight aspects of Jack (Milo Ventimiglia) and Rebecca’s (Mandy Moore) relationship.
“Having reviewed the Moonshadow episode of This Is Us, the Awards Committee noted that the entrant unfortunately miscalculated the proportion of scenes that were period versus contemporary. In fact, the episode is predominately period. The entry (and subsequent nomination) are thereby disqualified,” a Television Academy Spokesperson said in a statement to EW. “The sixth-place vote-getter — now the fifth nomination — will be identified by the accountants and will be revealed when the Televisions Academy’s final round viewing platform opens on Monday.”
Just last year, the Academy rescinded an Emmy nomination for Peter MacNicol after determining he had appeared in more than 50 percent of Veep’s episodes, disqualifying him for consideration in the guest actor in a comedy category. This paved the way for Peter Scolari to replace him in the nominations — and go on to win for his guest appearance on Girls.