By Oliver Gettell
October 09, 2015 at 12:00 PM EDT

New York Comic-Con can make for some interesting juxtapositions. Where else are you going to find a Game of Thrones cast member talking about Kermit the Frog’s new girlfriend, or an Agents of SHIELD star weighing in on copyright woes?

More importantly, where else would you learn what happens when the worlds of Robot Chicken and Pretty Little Liars collide?

During an interview with EW Radio hosts Mario Correa and Julia Cunningham, Robot Chicken‘s Breckin Meyer relayed an anecdote about running into an unnamed PLL star in the elevator.

“She’s definitely not coming to the RC panel,” Meyer joked. After a bit more ribbing, Meyer and fellow Robot Chicken masterminds Tom Root and Tom Sheppard appeared ready to move on, until Seth Green showed up and blew the lid off the Pretty Little Liars incident.

Check out the video interview above to see how it all went down.