By Christian Holub
November 03, 2016 at 12:20 PM EDT

Even outside of the Deadpool costume, Ryan Reynolds is still a prankster.

When Reynolds appeared on Conan Wednesday night, he came armed with multiple fake product ideas, like ham underwear and Civil War-themed sing-alongs. Each time, Reynolds wanted to “roll a clip” to demonstrate his idea, but host Conan O’Brien refused — at least until the last one. Promising “The Notebook 2, starring Ryan Reynolds and Conan McAdams,” Reynolds played a clip featuring him and O’Brien dressed up like Noah (Ryan Gosling) and Allie (Rachel McAdams) in the climactic scene of their beloved romance drama.

O’Brien was dressed in McAdams’ blue dress, and Reynolds in Gosling’s white shirt, as they acted through the actual dialogue of the scene (“I waited for you seven years”) before kissing each other passionately.

Watch the clip below.