By Nick Romano
Updated September 16, 2016 at 04:50 PM EDT
Albert L. Ortega/Getty Images; Rachel Murray/Getty Images for P.S. ARTS

What’s a guy to do when the girl of his dreams is the mother of the Antichrist? That’ll be Adam Scott‘s issue in Netflix’s horror-comedy Little Evil.

The Parks and Recreation actor will co-star in the film with Ant-Man and The Wasp‘s Evangeline Lilly, EW has confirmed. Eli Craig (Tucker and Dale vs Evil) will direct based on a script he wrote about a man named Gary (Scott) who marries a woman named Samantha (Lilly) and discovers her 6-year-old son may be the Antichrist.

Little Evil was originally set up at Universal in 2013, but it will now debut on Netflix sometime in 2017. Filming will kick off next week in Cleveland, Ohio.