Onscreen tough guy and Godfather star James Caan would seem like the last person you would want to prank in a film. But the characters portrayed by Logan Miller and Keir Gilchrist in new thriller The Good Neighbor clearly did not get that memo.

In director Kasra Farahani’s movie, the pair play mischevious high school kids who use surveillance equipment and other gadgets to trick Caan into thinking his house is haunted, before coming to the horrible realization that he is the last person they should have chosen upon whom to play this prank.

Yikes, yikes, and, thrice, yikes!

The Good Neighbor will be released in cinemas on Sept. 16, via Vertical Entertainment.

You can see exclusively see the trailer for The Good Neighbor above and the film’s poster, below.