By Allison Sadlier
Updated June 27, 2016 at 12:00 PM EDT
Mike Marsland/WireImage

Blake Lively has created the Frankenstein’s monster of hamburgers.

The actress, who stars now in The Shallows, explained her technique to PEOPLE and EW editorial director Jess Cagle during the latest episode of The Jess Cagle Interview.

As Lively revealed during the rapid-fire question-and-answer segment The Cagle Exercise, her go-to Umami Burger order involves the Manly Burger (which is topped with onion rings) and the Hatch burger (a.k.a. the “four chili burger”). “You cut them in half and you create one burger,” Lively said. “And then you give the other half to whoever you with.”

She added, “You eat it from the center and get a part of each.”

Other answers from Lively? Florence + The Machine’s “Dog Days Are Over” is the song she always dances to, Wizard of Oz is the movie she’s seen the most, and she’s really good at cooking (but bad at singing).

See the rest of Blake’s answers to “The Cagle Exercise” in the video above, and watch the full interview below.