By Gerrad Hall
Updated June 16, 2016 at 12:00 PM EDT
Credit: Michael Rozman/Warner Bros.
  • Movie

Diane Keaton was in the mood for love on Friday’s episode of The Ellen DeGeneres Show.

There to promote Finding Dory, where Keaton voices the mother of host Ellen DeGeneres’ title character, Keaton, with bottles of wine on the table next to her, revealed that she’s still, well, thirsty. Or, as Keaton puts it, “sexually frustrated.” So the talk show host helped her movie mom find a new lover with the help of a little game of Who’d You Rather.

In her first match-up, Keaton had to choose between Justin Bieber and Jared Leto.

“Well here’s where I have a problem — I don’t like to judge. I’d rather take them both,” she said to cheers from the audience. Admitting she has a “special feeling” for the pop star, she also pointed out his shirtless physique. “That’s a nice body, and he’s displaying it… and his hair, plus the nose. Don’t ever overlook a nose. For example, Mr. Leto has a very thin nose. I like a thin nose, but Mr. Bieber has a fatter nose, and I like that, too!”

When the game advanced, it was Al Pacino versus Jared Leto.

“He was a lover,” DeGeneres asked Keaton about Pacino.

“He once enjoyed being around me,” Keaton confirmed. “But only on occasion, not often.”

Leonardo DiCaprio, Jude Law, Jack Nicholson, Lenny Kravitz, and Zac Efron are among the other men Keaton has to choose from. See what she decided in the video below.

Finding Dory

  • Movie
  • PG
  • 97 minutes
  • Andrew Stanton