By Christopher Rosen
May 09, 2016 at 11:44 AM EDT
Michael Rozman/Warner Bros.

When Ellen DeGeneres isn’t scaring celebrities silly, she’s making them smash pies into their faces.

In DeGeneres’ Pie Face game, contestants must answer trivia questions correctly, lest they wind up with a cream pie flung at their face from a small catapult that they control. (Losers are forced to push a button on the catapult, anywhere from one to four times depending on what DeGeneres’ wheel of pie offers up. It all sounds complicated, but really it’s just about pies in faces.)

This week’s game pit Nick Jonas against his brother Joe Jonas, a brother on brother battle that resulted in a relative tie, meaning each Jonas brother had to hit the button until their pie headed north. It was Nick who won (“won”), taking a pie right to the face.

Fortunately for Joe, he was not left out of the mess. Nick took some excess cream filling and smashed it into his face as well.

Watch below.