By EW Staff
Updated May 02, 2016 at 01:06 PM EDT
Credit: EW

Dominic Monaghan can’t tell us his greatest story ever. Or his second greatest story ever. Or third. Or fourth. Or fifth. “To be fair, my greatest stories ever are illegal,” Monaghan joked in the latest edition of Greatest Story Ever Told.

Instead of dishing on one of those, the Lord of the Rings star still regaled us with a pretty sweet tale: the time the entire cast of Lord of the Rings got matching tattoos to celebrate their friendship.

“It was one of those beautiful moments, where we all felt like we had been through this war, this battle, together in a lot of different ways,” Monaghan remembered of their shared tattoos. “That really brought together that family feeling.”

Check out the full story behind the cast’s bonding above.

Lord of the Rings

  • Movie
  • Ralph Bakshi