By Dylan Kickham
Updated March 21, 2016 at 07:03 PM EDT

As the Beauty and the Beast huntsman Gaston well knows, no one is better than him. But who is better at channeling that manly arrogance? When Hugh Jackman, who played Gaston in the stage musical, and Luke Evans, who will play Gaston in the upcoming live-action remake, were both guests on The Jonathan Ross Show this weekend, it seemed like the perfect time to find out.

Ross challenged the two men to sing Gaston’s eponymous song together. Luckily, Jackman’s Eddie the Eagle co-star Taron Egerton was more than happy to play Gaston’s doting lackey LeFou, bursting into the song’s prologue without any hesitation. And with beer steins in hand, they were off.

Check out the smirky Gaston-off above, and see who you think might be the most “burly and brawny.”

Beauty and the Beast (2017)

  • Movie
  • PG
  • 129 minutes
  • Bill Condon