By Madeline Boardman
October 11, 2015 at 12:00 PM EDT
Everett Collection

In 1998’s Parent Trap reboot, Annie James and Hallie Parker have one big moment in their shared isolation cabin when they realize that not only do they have the same parents, but they were both born on October 11. The fictional twins, famously played by Lindsay Lohan, celebrate their 30th birthday on Tuesday.

In honor of the trouble-causing camp-goers’ big day, bump a little “Do You Believe In Magic” and test your knowledge of The Parent Trap in EW’s quiz by identifying whether it was Hallie or Annie who said the quote.