By Dalton Ross
September 14, 2015 at 02:22 PM EDT
Monty Brinton/CBS
  • TV Show

It is one of pop culture’s most famous finger wags. Kimmi Kappenberg had a sliiiiiiiight disagreement with Alicia on Survivor: The Australian Outback about how often the tribe should be eating their chickens. Their argument ended with Alicia’s finger waving back and forth in Kimmi’s face.

So naturally when we spoke with Kimmi out on location for Survivor: Cambodia—Second Chance, we had to ask: What will she do if someone hits her up with another finger wag? “I will not break someone’s finger if they wag it in my face,” says Kimmi. “I am more controlled now. I will react. I will say my peace, but I will probably not be quite as aggressive as I was.”

We’ll see. That’s easy to say, but it is often a different matter altogether once you get tired, wet, and hungry. But after being passed over for other all-star seasons, did Kimmi lose hope that she would ever be asked back to play Survivor? “I always hoped,” says Kimmi. “I mean, I wasn’t holding my breath that I would have a second chance, but I was definitely hopeful. And as time goes by you kind of think, maybe I’m expired. But it honestly feels like everything in my personal life was lined up and this was a great time, because had they called me earlier it probably wouldn’t have been a good time in my personal life. So I think this was the right time.”

We also asked Kimmi if she formed any pre-game alliances back in the United States during the fan voting period, and she outed one potential player as forming a coalition. “There was actually a lot of correspondence from people regarding a Culpepper alliance,” says Kimmi, who also adds that she did not take part in any early alliances because she worried that they were actually ruses set up by the network.

“I didn’t talk to anybody because I was just so afraid that it was a baited trap by CBS to say, ‘Hey, you’re not supposed to go and talk to somebody.’ So I don’t know. Those other people that didn’t make it — maybe they were caught in a trap. So that’s in my head. I wasn’t responding or corresponding with anybody.”

To be clear, the reason the people that did not make it did not make it is not because they took part in pre-game alliances. But I love the paranoia and conspiracy theories being thrown out here. Absolutely love it.

To see our chat with Kimmi, click on the video at the top of the post. And for more Survivor scoop, follow me on Twitter @DaltonRoss.

Monty Brinton/CBS

Related Stories

Abi from Survivor: Second Chance says ‘I was a brute’ last time she played

Find out why Jeremy from Survivor: Cambodia—Second Chance still does not trust Keith

Joe Anglim reveals status of man bun on Survivor: Cambodia—Second Chance

Why Shirin is looking forward to playing with ‘smarter people’ in Survivor: Cambodia—Second Chance

Kelly Wiglesworth says ‘it’s always difficult to relive the end’ of Survivor: Borneo

Jeff Probst names the players with no shot to win Survivor: Cambodia—Second Chance

Keith from Survivor: Second Chance admits he had ‘no strategy’ last time he played

Survivor: Second Chance player Monica Padilla relives her complete tribe meltdown in Samoa

Survivor: Second Chance: Woo says he won’t make same epic mistake twice

Survivor: Second Chance player Peih-Gee Law on the advice Amanda Kimmel gave her

Survivor: Second Chance player Stephen Fishbach says ‘it haunts me every day, the fact I didn’t win’

WANT MORE EW? Subscribe now to keep up with the latest in movies, television and music.

Keep up with all the latest from last night’s television by subscribing to our newsletter. Head here for more details.

Episode Recaps

Jeff Probst leads adventures in the ultimate (and original) reality series.
  • TV Show
  • 39
  • 05/31/00
  • Charlie Parsons
Complete Coverage
Available For Streaming On