By Jonathon Dornbush
August 27, 2015 at 01:33 PM EDT

Has Harry Potter’s innocent smile appeared just a little too blameless all these years? What if Draco Malfoy was right all this time, and Harry was secretly the villain all along?

No, that’s not the subject of a new fan theory, but it is the route a new fan-made trailer takes, recutting Harry Potter’s cinematic exploits — most notably in Prisoner of Azkaban — to make the Boy Who Lived look like he’s the one looking to cause trouble.

Harry’s angrier or more impassioned moments are cleverly reshuffled in the new clip for a much darker take on the titular star. Maybe it isn’t Voldemort, the dementors, and the several dozen other threats popping up on a daily basis that everyone needs to watch out for at Hogwarts.

Related Stories

Oklahoma teacher turns her classroom into a Harry Potter paradise

See a heartbreaking mashup of Harry Potter & ‘See You Again’

J.K. Rowling explains American wizarding government on Twitter, says there won’t be a Harry Potter TV show