Luke Bryan & Jimmy Fallon have some trouble with Catchphrase on The Tonight Show

Country musician Luke Bryan and Wet Hot American Summer star Christopher Meloni joined Jimmy Fallon and Steve Higgins for a game of Catchphrase on Monday night’s Tonight Show.

A Brooklyn native, Fallon tried his best to describe Coney Island to Georgia-born Bryan. He used the Cyclone rollercoaster and ice cream as clues, but Bryan insisted he wasn’t from New York and “Conehead” and “Snow Cone” were the two closest guesses he could muster. “It has nothing to do with cone,” Fallon said.

After learning the answer was Coney Island, Bryan interrupted Fallon: “Hey, Hot Dog eating contest?” (It’s the New York event that transcends geography.)

Fallon and Bryan fared a little better in round 2, when the answer was “Karate Chop.”

•Donald Trump (okay, Jimmy Fallon) calls everyone a deviant after Megyn Kelly comments

•Taylor Kitsch & Jimmy Fallon played Beer Hockey on Friday night

•Jimmy Fallon thanks Jon Stewart for giving Fox News ‘their moment of zen’