By Jonathon Dornbush
July 31, 2015 at 02:51 PM EDT

The most interesting thing about Ed Helms playing a round of Shag, Marry, Kill, about his former costars is not his actual answer. It’s the sheer wave of panic that clearly washes over him and his instantaneous attempt to not show that panic as he’s given his options for the game.

A viewer called in to Watch What Happens Live on Thursday to ask Helms to choose whether he’d shag, marry or kill his following former costars: Jennifer Aniston, Rashida Jones, and his onscreen wife in Vacation, Christina Applegate.

Watch the video below to see Helms’ choices, and his concern about having to make the difficult choice. Hopefully the producers behind Vacation don’t mind his answer.

Vacation is now in theaters.

Related Stories

Ed Helms rescues Bear Grylls on Running Wild (well, sort of)

Ed Helms debuts ‘ridiculously earnest’ new album with bluegrass band The Lonesome Trio

Vacation: EW review