By Lynette Rice
June 08, 2015 at 09:26 PM EDT

Would you buy a painting that was personally spit by Joe Jonas?

The singer/teen idol tries to demonstrate that he has what it takes to be a great artist — or at least a fairly entertaining blue man — in the next installment of I Can Do That on NBC.

For the first time, The Blue Man Group allows a couple of complete outsiders to don the paint (and bald heads) to perform with them. In this case, those outsiders are actor Alan Ritchson and Jonas, who actually spits paint out on a canvas. Take a look:

In case you’ve missed the first few episodes, I Can Do That features six entertainers who compete by performing very unique acts. Besides Jonas and Ritchson, the show also stars Cheryl Burke, Ciara, Nicole Scherzinger and stand-up comedian Jeff Dye.

I Can Do That airs Tuesdays at 10 p.m. on NBC.