By Andrea Towers
Updated June 03, 2015 at 07:30 PM EDT
Jordan Strauss/Invision/AP

Dedicated fans of Chris Evans know that the Captain America actor has a background in performing arts, which is not entirely surprising since the actor grew up in a family full of performers. But unless you’re a relative or maybe a Marvel cast member—or unless Evans decides to come to Broadway—you’re probably never going to have the chance to see the actor do any kind of singing — until now.

Scott Evans, who has been routinely seen making appearances alongside his brother on The Tonight Show, recently uploaded a YouTube video that showed the brothers playing around on the piano while singing James Taylor’s “Fire and Rain.” The short clip was posted with the caption, “Chris and I messing around over Memorial Day weekend. Unfortunately we had the giggles and couldn’t make it through the whole thing without laughing for here is just a tease… With some sung apologies to each other. :)” Although the video cuts off as both brothers adorably mess up the lyrics, there’s more than enough footage to make your heart melt.

Evans is currently in the middle of shooting Captain America: Civil War, due out May 2016. Paging Joe and Anthony Russi: Is it too much to hope for a scene that includes Captain America singing to the Avengers? Perhaps a post credit scene can be arranged…

Jordan Strauss/Invision/AP