By C. Molly Smith
Updated May 23, 2015 at 09:31 PM EDT
Credit: NBC

Jimmy Fallon and the Ragtime Gals called the Police Friday night, performing a barbershop quartet version of “Roxanne” on The Tonight Show. Best of all, the voice of the original hit, Sting, was there to take the lead, soloing the first half of the song. Fallon followed about halfway through (watch out for his literal demonstration of the lyrics through hip thrusting, and Sting’s comedic disapproval, at 1:11). Now, did the late-night a cappella cover do the original justice? You be the judge: