Anna Kendrick’s interview on The Late Show with David Letterman got a little weird on Tuesday night.
The Into the Woods star took a break from discussing the upcoming Disney musical to call out a particularly suspicious-looking Christmas gift.
Letterman had shown off a toy earlier in the evening, a puppet cat’s paw for the aspiring ventriloquist in your life. When Kendrick appeared, however, she had some concerns about the toy’s origins, suspecting it was originally meant for another use.
For more information on Into the Woods, devoid of any adult toy discussion, check out EW‘s cover story about the film.