By Dan Snierson
Updated September 25, 2014 at 08:02 PM EDT

Here at EW, we try to capture the essence of the celebrities we photograph and show them as they truly exist in the world. Of course, everyone wants to be seen in the best light, literally. But two of our subjects were so unhappy with each other’s appearance, they demanded a few changes. Given that these two people were Keegan-Michael Key and Jordan Peele, guest editors of this week’s issue of EW, we had little choice but to slightly enhance their image with just a few tweaks—a mustache here, a bird there. (Click here for the full-size image.) Anyway, it’s probably just best that you watch the video below.