By Natalie Abrams
August 28, 2014 at 06:23 AM EDT
Jimmy Kimmel Live

Jimmy Kimmel lived out his fantasy on Wednesday after staging a mini-Friends reunion on Jimmy Kimmel Live!

The late night host enlisted Must-See TV alums Jennifer Aniston, Courteney Cox and Lisa Kudrow to act out some of his own Friends fan-fiction that he had written years ago, in which he inserted himself into the show’s script.

Kimmel surprised his guest Aniston with an exact replica of Monica and Rachel’s apartment from the NBC series. Though the actress denied his request to wear the Rachel wig, she played along as Kimmel portrayed Ross in a scene about how great the paleontologist is in bed. Cox and Kudrow surprised the audience, entering through the photo frame-adorned door to also compliment Ross’ sexual prowess. Why weren’t Joey and Chandler in the scene? They both died after Marcel the monkey gave them rabies. Check out the video below: