By Ariana Bacle
Updated May 21, 2014 at 02:05 PM EDT
Credit: Douglas Gorenstein/NBC

Charlize Theron can do just about anything — except sing. Or win a game of charades.

The Million Ways to Die in the West star went on The Tonight Show Tuesday evening, where she teamed up with announcer Steve Higgins to play a game of charades against Jimmy Fallon and Penny Dreadful star Josh Hartnett. Meaning we got to see Theron act out all the ways one can commit murder when she picked Murder She Wrote as her clue. And we thought Monster was the end of her killing career!

Watch the clip below to see Hartnett pretend to be Godzilla and Fallon try to act out Tina Turner’s “Private Dancer.” Spoiler: It involves a sort-of lap dance:

The Tonight Show

  • TV Show
  • In Season