By Mandi Bierly
April 28, 2014 at 07:11 PM EDT

She plays a U.S. Marshal on TV, but how good is Justified actress Erica Tazel’s aim in real life? To find out, we invited her to the EW Corral for a three-part NERF challenge dubbed the TV Star Shootout: In Round 1, she called out targets on the wall of covers in our main conference room (Joss Whedon cast her in an episode of Firefly, hence her guilt). In Round 2, she faced off with five staffers in a series of quick draws in our kitchen (EW’s Darren Franich is the one who needs to apologize there). And in Round 3, she took to the cubicles to pull on Justified bad guys (with one surprise).* Watch her in action below: 

* It’s not that she refused to fire at fan-favorite Dewey Crowe, but that she is a Good Wife fan who offered to perform CPR on our Will Gardner target afterward.