By Mandi Bierly
April 26, 2014 at 06:00 PM EDT

What happens when you get the four girls who share the titular role in Broadway’s Matilda the Musical together for an interview? You find out which one of them is allowed to watch Grimm (Ava Ulloa), who’s keeping your love of Saved by the Bell and Full House alive (Ripley Sobo), and who can tell you all about Jim Henson’s Creature Shop Challenge and Face Off (Paige Brady and Gabriella Pizzolo).

You also learn that they joke about jazz hands and that there are still kids you’d like to hear sing songs from Frozen.

Watch them take the EW Pop Culture Personality Test below.