By Jake Perlman
Updated April 24, 2014 at 12:00 PM EDT
Michael Becker/Fox

For the first time, the contestants got to sing two solo songs Wednesday night, one country and one rock ‘n roll. With too many guitars and not enough personality, the final six continued to make similar mistakes from week’s past. And now that mistake may prove fatal as one more singer was unplugged for good.

WARNING! Spoilers ahead about tonight’s elimination!

C.J. Harris (far right) is the next Idol saying goodbye. Jessica Meuse and Harris, both natives of Alabama were the bottom two.

That leaves Caleb, Jena, Sam, Alex and Jessica in the top 5. Next week’s theme is America’s Choice with Jason Mraz mentoring!

What do you think – Did the right singer go home? Full recap coming soon!