By James Hibberd
November 01, 2013 at 07:41 PM EDT

Lifetime has just crossed off The Client List.

The cable network is axing Jennifer Love Hewitt’s latest TV series after two seasons.

In addition to modest ratings, EW confirmed the network and the show’s studio Sony Pictures Television conflicted with Hewitt about a possible third season storyline. Hewitt wanted her real-life fiance Brian Hallisay to play the father of her character’s child on the show.

Between the second season concluding with a mere 2.1 million viewers, and Lifetime planning to bring back dramas Devious Maids, The Witches Of East End, as well as developing other shows, the network let The Client List‘s third season pickup option lapse.