By Laura Hertzfeld
Updated August 30, 2013 at 07:00 PM EDT

Mamie Gummer and Kristen Bell may play friends who have grown apart in their new film The Lifeguard, but they certainly agree that the guy of their 90s teen fantasies was none other than Home Improvement hottie Jonathan Taylor Thomas — obvi!

When the pair took our Pop Culture Personality Test, we also learned about Bell’s obsession with the new Discovery Channel series Naked and Afraid.

Check out the quiz below! The Lifeguard is currently playing in theaters.