By EW Staff
June 13, 2013 at 08:15 PM EDT
John Russo/NBC

Christina Aguilera’s collection of folding fans, JLo’s curve-hugging (midriff-baring, slit-up-to-there, bedazzled) dresses, Nina Garcia’s impeccably tailored designer ensembles. Who deserves the title of “Best Dressed Reality TV Judge” and who should be sent packing? Check out our full bracket here and vote in the polls below to determine who will move on to the next round. Today — the 8 judges in our “Feuding Fashion Plates” conference face off. 

Tyra Banks (America’s Next Top Model) vs. Naomi Campbell (The Face)

John Russo/NBC

Heidi Klum (Project Runway) vs. Nina Garcia (Project Runway)

Padma Lakshmi (Top Chef) vs. Carrie Ann Inaba (Dancing with the Stars)

Jessica Simpson (Fashion Star) vs. Nicole Richie (Fashion Star)

Just catching up? See the first-round competitors in the “Dueling Divas” conference.

Fashion Face-Off: Who is the best dressed reality TV judge?

“Dueling Divas” conference

  • TV Show
  • In Season
Complete Coverage