By Hillary Busis
Updated April 23, 2013 at 05:40 PM EDT

Move over, Alison Brie — another sitcom star is gunning for your virtual crown.

One week after the Community actress imitated a set of popular memes for a much-watched YouTube video, “Internet Games with Paul F. Tompkins” has drafted New Girl‘s Jess-romancer to do the same. As a competitive person who “can’t not try,” Jake Johnson naturally gives his all when asked to strut like a jaunty Leonardo DiCaprio, widen his eyes to look like Nicolas Cage as the “You Don’t Say?” guy, grin like Trollface, and frown like Grumpy Cat. (As a YouTube commenter points out, the last look is just like Nick Miller’s turtle face.)

And if you just can’t get enough Jake, his full 17-minute interview with Paul F. Tompkins can be found below.

Read more: