By James Hibberd
April 17, 2013 at 03:29 PM EDT

It’s not you, it’s the show!

Even though ratings for The Voice climbed a tad Tuesday night, an improved lead-in didn’t help NBC’s Ready for Love. The Eva Longoria-produced new romance reality show fell 13 percent for its second episode this week.

And Ready for Love wasn’t the only new reality show struggling last night — ABC’s Splash has sunk to the bottom of the 8 p.m. hour. While veteran reality hits like ABC’s Dancing With the Stars and Fox’s Hell’s Kitchen have both seen much better days.

The one reality show singing a great story last night was The Voice, which continues to perform strong week after week and matched its Tuesday season high last night.

Here’s your full chart: