By James Hibberd
November 15, 2012 at 04:20 PM EST

She’s back!

C’mon everybody, aren’t you excited? NBC’s Whitney returned Wednesday night. How’d she do? Would you believe Whitney pulled 4.2 million and a 1.4 among adults 18-49? Why, that’s as good as the launch of Animal Practice in this time period earlier this fall … what do you mean, Animal Practice was cancelled?

Ohh. Well. Whitney also tied its series low. Lead-out Guys With Kids (3.8 million, 1.3) was down a tick from its last original, which is a shame because the hope was that these two would boost each other. There was also NBC’s Chicago Fire (5.7 million, 1.6), which you’ll recall last week shot up to a series high with a special Voice lead-in. Last night it fell 27 percent back down to the same rating as a couple weeks ago to rank third at 10 p.m.

Overall, Modern Family (11.9 million, 4.6) was the night’s top-rated show, and nearly steady with last week. The rest of ABC’s lineup dipped a bit, including 10 p.m.’s Nashville (5.9 million, 1.8) which slipped 10 percent after receiving its full-season order earlier this week. Over on The CW, another freshman drama, Arrow (3.8 million, 1.2), ticked back down in the demo, though enjoyed its largest overall audience since its premiere.

Did anybody climb among adults 18-49? Yes. Fox’s X-Factor (8.1 million, 2.9), not having to face The Voice this week, bounced 12 percent. Also, CBS’ CSI (10.8 million, 2.4) ticked up 4 percent.

New and improved chart! Now sorted by program:


FOX 8-10P X-FACTOR #3 2.9 8,088
ABC 8:00P MIDDLE #5 2.5 8,738
8:30P NEIGHBORS #8 1.9 6,743
9:00P MODERN FAMILY- #1 4.6 11,902
9:30P SUBURGATRY #6t 2.4 7,216
10-11P NASHVILLE #9 1.8 5,892
CBS 8-9P SURVIVOR- #4 2.6 9,979
9-10P CRIMINAL MINDS #2 3.0 12,133
10-11P CSI #6t 2.4 10,811
NBC 8:00P WHITNEY P #12 1.4 4,226
8:30P GUYS WITH KIDS #13 1.3 3,818
9-10P LAW&O:SVU #10t 1.6 5,733
10-11P CHICAGO FIRE #10t 1.6 5,719
CW 8-9P ARROW #14 1.2 3,799
9-10P SUPERNATURAL #15 1.0 2,304