Credit: Nicole Wilder/Bravo

And then there were three. But after tonight, there can only be one. Syfy’s Face Off is just hours away from announcing the winning makeup artist of its third season, and this time, in a Face Off first, the fans – not the judges – get to decide who will be crowned the winner.

Last night’s episode, “Immortal Enemies,” functioned as part one of a two-episode finale and featured Nicole Chilelli, Derek Garcia and Laura Tyler’s last designs on the show. With the help of two eliminated contestants each, the finalists created two makeups, a demon and the good witch who hunts him down. The good witches had to represent one of the four classical elements; Tyler chose Earth, Chilelli picked Water and Garcia went with Fire.

Teaming the finalists with eliminated contestants did create some tension – it wasn’t easy for Roy Wooley to help Chilelli given his feelings about Face Off‘s twist to give Chilelli a second chance after she had been eliminated – but each finalist was ultimately able to lead their two assistants in creating makeups that would appear in a stunt show.

Though this time around the judges won’t have a say in who wins, they still supplied viewers with their thoughts on the witches and demons. They praised Tyler’s white birch tree-inspired Earth Witch, but Glenn Hetrick disliked Tyler’s choice to have her pollution-spreading demon look like it comes from a different world than the witch and said it “doesn’t feel like Laura’s work.” Chilelli’s coral headdress for the Water Witch earned top marks, as did her demon’s teeth made out of feather quills, but the angular, ram-horned head on her demon was criticized. The judges admired the profile and silhouette of both Garcia’s Lava Witch and his demon that had been trapped underground for years.

Neville Page also gave his overall impression of each finalist. He declared Tyler the “best makeup artist” of the bunch, and said Garcia is “best at communicating his ideas because of his drawing skills.” For Chilelli he had plenty of praise about how she had “knocked it out of the park” since her return to the show.

Fans can submit their votes for the winner now until 7 p.m. Wednesday on the Face Off website or via phone. The winner won’t be revealed until the finale, but Syfy is keeping track of how much buzz each contestant is getting on Twitter. Chilelli is currently the top trending of the three.

Host McKenzie Westmore told EW her advice for casting their votes for the winner:

“What I love about Face Off is that it’s never a popularity contest. It really is about the artistry. And I just encourage the fans to keep that in mind,” she said. “Really look at their body of work and, most importantly, [last night’s] show and how they feel the makeups are even before they are put through the test of the stunt show. How did they look on their models? Do they look like something that could be camera-ready?”

Tonight’s finale will air live on the east coast at 10 p.m. on Syfy. In all other time zones, a tape delayed episode will air.

As host, Westmore doesn’t get a chance on the show to voice her opinions of the contestants’ work, but she told EW which makeups were the most memorable – both the good and the bad – for her this season. Read on to see her take on some of the designs that earned contestants the honor of top look and some that got them sent home.

Credit: Lewis Jacobs/NBC

Roy Wooley and Rod Maxwell, Star Wars challenge, episode 3.01

The season’s first spotlight challenge teamed up Rod Maxwell and Roy Wooley, who immediately showed off his fabrication skills with a robotic exoskeleton for their round little alien. “So impressive,” Westmore said of the design. “That really was amazing what they pulled off in that short amount of time and for the first challenge too.”

Credit: Lewis Jacobs/NBC

Rod Maxwell, kids’ monsters challenge, episode 3.07

Though Maxwell got off to a judges-wowing start, he was eliminated in the season’s seventh episode when his realization of a nine-year-old’s monster sketch, with its big, fat head, was too similar to many of his previous designs in the season. “I felt bad for Rod because there was such a specific direction that he was given,” Westmore said. “He was trying to bring [Sofia’s drawing] to life. But it kind of still stuck with that same pattern of what he’d been previously doing. And it just was an unfortunate thing that it turned out the way that it did.”

Credit: Lewis Jacobs/NBC

Roy Wooley, Grimm challenge, episode 3.11

Wooley earned a spot on a few more episodes than Maxwell, getting eliminated last week after the Grimm-inspired challenge, when he focused more on makeup and less on fabrication. “It was unfortunate with Roy because he really is an incredibly talented artist, and he’s an amazing fabricator, but one of the problems that was being seen week after week was that he wasn’t finishing his projects,” Westmore said. “He would bring out amazing stuff, but they weren’t fully finished, while other [contestants] would be finished. And that was the tough thing with letting Roy go with that episode because he is so good and he is so talented. I know the fans were very upset, as they should be because he is so good, but it was time after time of unfinished – amazing stuff – but unfinished, and then when [the model in the snake makeup] came out, it just wasn’t up to par with the other ones.”

Credit: Lewis Jacobs/NBC

Laura Tyler, kids’ monsters challenge, episode 3.07

While Maxwell was eliminated for his kid’s imagination-inspired monster, Tyler scored her first top look with her vampire/dragon baby monster. “I loved Laura’s,” Westmore said. “I know that that was a very tough challenge for [judge] Glenn [Hetrick]. He’s not really into the more soft side, shall we say. But Laura’s won him over. She won that challenge. It was adorable.”

Follow Emily on Twitter: @EmilyNRome

Read more:

Face Off
  • TV Show